Human vs. AI-Generated Art: Are Human Artists Redundant?

 Introduction: The Age-Old Question of Artistic Relevance


The rapid development of artificial intelligence has brought significant advancements in various fields, and the world of art is no exception. As AI-generated or AI-derivative art pieces continue to emerge, a question has been raised: are human artists becoming redundant? This question sparks a fascinating debate, prompting some to argue that human creativity is irreplaceable, while others claim that AI's potential to revolutionize the art world is only just beginning. Several studies have sought to explore this issue by determining whether people prefer human-created original art to AI-generated or AI-derivative art.

The Studies: Comparing Preferences for Human and AI-Generated Art

"Artificial Intelligence and the Perception of Art" (2020)

In this study, researchers attempted to determine the preferences of participants when faced with human-created and AI-generated art. The participants were not informed of the origin of the artworks. They were asked to rate the aesthetics, creativity, and overall quality of the pieces. The results indicated that the participants could not reliably distinguish between the two types of art. However, when the participants were informed of the origin, they tended to rate the human-created art more favorably.

"AI Art: Exploring the Human-AI Creativity Relationship" (2021)

In this study, the researchers examined how people perceive AI-generated and AI-derivative art compared to human-created art. The study incorporated three categories: human-created art, AI-generated art, and AI-derivative art (art created with the assistance of AI). The participants were asked to evaluate the artwork based on creativity, emotional impact, and technical skill. The results revealed a clear preference for human-created art, with AI-generated and AI-derivative art receiving relatively similar ratings.

Conclusion: The Future of Art and the Role of Human Artists

While the aforementioned studies suggest that people still prefer human-created art, it is essential to recognize that the world of art is continually evolving. AI-generated and AI-derivative art are relatively new concepts, and as AI technology improves, the gap between human and AI-generated art may diminish.

However, it is unlikely that human artists will become redundant. Art is more than just aesthetics and creativity; it is a reflection of human emotions, thoughts, and experiences that AI may never fully replicate. The growing presence of AI-generated art in the art world is not necessarily a threat to human artists. Instead, it could be seen as an opportunity for collaboration, where AI can serve as a tool that empowers human artists to explore new creative possibilities.

In conclusion, human-created art still holds a special place in our hearts, and human artists will continue to be relevant in the foreseeable future. However, it is important to remain open to the potential of AI-generated and AI-derivative art, as these new forms of expression may challenge our perceptions of creativity and further enrich the artistic landscape.



Visit: https://isabelledutoit.com/ for more Human Created Art.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Clone Command Bar Button in Model Driven App: Order & OrderDetails

Image
This article is a quick overview of the process of making an ORDER & ORDERDETAIL  Clone button in one Action. When the user clicks on the Clone  button, the system will automatically create a copy of the order with all the related orderdetail (line items). This in the context of Model-Driven Power Apps using Dataverse and Power-Fx low-code tools. Prototype ERD for this Order Entry System Visit https://online.visual-paradigm.com/ if you want to use this tool  Now, Let's make a custom command bar button Start Here: make.powerapps.com Make a new command bar, command button, on the command bar. Then, on the Main Form using Power Fx formula below, we will build a Clone function that not only Clones the Parent Order Record but also the related Child OrderDetails (line items). It also sets the OrderDate to the current date.  Model-Driven Apps: Modern Command Bar Customization  Credit to Scott Durow for the original version. Below is modified version. (Link:...
Read more

Model-Driven Apps: Modern Command Bar Customization

Image
Model-Driven Apps: Modern Command Bar Customization SOURCE: Credit to Scott Durow Link:   https://youtu.be/Jq2GLgNEcp0?si=K4xodRYmI_fvjNVd Summary of Topics: ✨How to clone a record including child records Note: Instead of editing the fx formula directly, select ... Edit next to Table Name, Edit Command Bar Form and +New Command called 'Clone' and give it the Clone icon. OnSelect FX formula can be edited easily via the Component Library (similar to Canvas App experience). The trick is to use the With syntax to also clone the child records for the Purchase order line item in this example! 1) Create a Clone Button: 2) Action: Run formula (fx open formula bar), Save and Publish 3) Open component library and edit your fx formula their (easier) and similar to canvas app designer 4) First, We can make the formula just copy the Parent record, then enhance it for child records later This will make a copy of the entire parent record. Optionally you can select just certain fields. or...
Read more

Knowledge shared is power squared!

Image
  Knowledge shared is power squared! Microsoft Power Apps documentation: Discover how to make the most of Power Apps with online training courses, docs, and videos covering product capabilities and how-to articles. Learn how to quickly build low-code apps that modernize processes and solve tough business challenges in your organization using Power Apps  *power-apps maker | Microsoft Learn   The power platform and power apps are amazing tools that finally allow citizen developers to create solutions and innovate using low-code/no-code tools often without the "evil corporate IT" environment that wants to block everything and make us wait forever and charge a fortune...  "Heck, If I have to pay IT to be blocked and wait forever, I can find other ways to get stuff done...." Inviting all Power Apps Makers to create, learn, share, and connect! Join our Power Apps Community on Discord for free and discuss all things Power Apps!   
Read more